This system has been covered in a number of books by Dr Alexander Elder.
From the book “Entries and Exits, Visit To Sixteen Trading Rooms”, it seems that this system is used as a censorship system rather than an automatic trading system.
This system uses the slope of the moving average and MACD histogram to classify the system trends. There are 4 types of markets:
Type | Slope of EMA | Slope of MACD Histogram | Trading Message |
1 | Up | Up | Long or stand aside, no shorting |
2 | Down | Down | Short or stand aside, no buying |
3 | Up | Down | Either long or short |
4 | Down | Up | Either long or short |
When the slope of EMA is up, it shows that inertia favors the bulls. The reverse is true for the bears. When the slope of EMA is down, bears have the upper hand.
The slope of the MACD histogram shows the power of the bulls and bears. When slope of MACD histogram is up, the bulls are gaining strength. When slope of MACD histogram is down, the bears are growing stronger.
Let’s do a case study to see whether the method works.
I have chosen FXI and STI respectively. FXI is iShares FTSE/Xinhua China 25 Index and STI is the Straits Times Index.
The rules are as follows:
Entry
- Slope of weekly EMA is up. 26 week EMA is used
- Slope of weekly MACD Histogram is up. 12-26-9 weekly MACD Histogram is used.
- When both conditions 1 and 2 wait for conditions 4 and 5 to be satisfied
- Slope of daily EMA is up. 13 day EMA is used
- Slope of daily MACD Histogram is up. 12-26-9 daily MACD Histogram is used.
Exit
- Slope of weekly EMA is down. 26 week EMA is used
- Slope of weekly MACD Histogram is down. 12-26-9 weekly MACD Histogram is used.
Simulation data is from 2003 to 20 Mar 2008
The trading record for STI is as follows:
Entry Date | Entry Price | Exit Date | Exit Price | Change (%) | Draw Down % | Max Gain % | Bars Held |
1/5/2004 | 1,797.75 | 5/17/2004 | 1,745.89 | -2.88 | -2.8847 | 6.4069 | 91 |
6/28/2004 | 1,807.15 | 10/24/2005 | 2,249.57 | 24.48 | -0.2047 | 32.792 | 337 |
11/7/2005 | 2,268.76 | 5/29/2006 | 2,449.61 | 7.97 | -1.5828 | 17.5237 | 139 |
8/18/2006 | 2,477.94 | 8/13/2007 | 3,375.02 | 36.2 | -2.0537 | 48.8567 | 246 |
8/27/2007 | 3,426.19 | 11/19/2007 | 3,454.70 | 0.83 | -5.1436 | 14.0089 | 59 |
12/3/2007 | 3,549.47 | 12/17/2007 | 3,417.08 | -3.73 | -3.7298 | 2.0389 | 10 |
The trading record for FXI:
Entry Date | Entry Price | Exit Date | Exit Price | Change (%) | Draw Down % | Max Gain % | Bars Held |
6/13/2005 | 53.767 | 10/17/2005 | 58.08 | 8.02 | -0.5933 | 18.7476 | 88 |
11/14/2005 | 57.819 | 6/12/2006 | 69.242 | 19.76 | -0.7939 | 43.4096 | 143 |
7/3/2006 | 76.714 | 3/5/2007 | 89.305 | 16.41 | -5.8268 | 52.0596 | 167 |
3/26/2007 | 102.393 | 1/7/2008 | 167.37 | 63.46 | -3.0881 | 111.9071 | 198 |
This method is able to avoid trading in the market when the trend is in sideways mode. The average gain is higher than the average loss which is typical for trend trading method.
4 comments:
Where do you find the program to trade using this system?
It is certainly interesting for me to read the post. Thanks the author for it. I like such themes and anything connected to this matter. I definitely want to read a bit more soon.
Sincerely yours
Steave Markson
Nice blog you got here. I'd like to read a bit more about that topic. Thank you for sharing that data.
Joan Stepsen
Sacramento escort service
for the exit did you use conditions 1 AND 2 or conditions 1 OR 2 ?
Post a Comment